Frequently Asked Questions
Real answers to the questions that keep people up at night — grounded in scripture, free from religion.
What Does "Dying to Self" Actually Mean?
This phrase is one of the most misread in Christian vocabulary. It is not about self-punishment, self-erasure, or trying harder.
​
The short answer
Dying to self is not something you do. It is something that has already been done.
​
The death Paul describes in scripture is not a daily spiritual discipline you perform through effort and suppression. It is an accomplished fact: the self that was defined by sin, by striving apart from God, by the independent pursuit of life outside of union with Him, was crucified with Christ. Past tense. Galatians 2:20 puts it plainly: "I have been crucified with Christ. It is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me." The tense is perfect: completed action with ongoing effect. Paul is not describing a standard to attain. He is describing a reality that has already occurred.
​
The common understanding of "dying to self" turns it into a form of spiritual self-management: suppress your desires, minimize your personality, grind down your preferences, and call the result holiness. But that reading has almost nothing to do with what Paul is actually saying. And it produces, reliably, not transformation but exhaustion.
What "self" is actually dying
The confusion starts with what "self" refers to in these texts.
​
When Paul speaks of the old self being crucified (Romans 6:6), he is not talking about your personality, your individuality, or your God-given desires. He is talking about the self that operated independently of God, the self that looked to sin to meet needs that only God can meet, the self that was defined by performance, fear, striving, and the desperate attempt to secure life apart from its source.
​
That self is not who you are in Christ. It is who you were before you were united with Him in His death. And the consistent language Paul uses for that self is past tense. It was crucified. You died to sin (Romans 6:2). You have died and your life is now hidden with Christ in God (Colossians 3:3). Not: you must daily kill it. It already died.
This is the foundation that completely changes what "dying to self" means in practice. You are not trying to accomplish a death that has not yet happened. You are learning to live from one that has.
What Luke 9:23 actually means
This is the passage most often used to teach dying to self as a daily discipline: "If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross daily and follow me."
​
The phrase "take up your cross" carried a specific, visceral meaning to the people Jesus was speaking to. A cross was not a symbol of spiritual difficulty or self-denial in a general sense. In the first century, a cross meant one thing: public execution. Taking up your cross was the posture of someone who had surrendered all claim to their own life.
Jesus is not describing a discipline of suppressing your personality. He is describing a fundamental orientation: the decision to no longer treat your life as your own, to release the grip on self-determination, and to follow Him into a way of living that operates from a different source entirely. It is a surrender of autonomy, not a punishment of self.
​
And notice the word "daily." This does not mean the death must be re-achieved every morning. It means the surrender is not a one-time decision made at conversion and then forgotten. It is a lived posture, a daily return to the truth that your life is not your own and that His life in you is what you are living from. The daily part is not effort. It is orientation.
The difference between denial and suppression
There is a practical and important distinction between denying yourself and suppressing yourself, and the two are not the same thing.
​
Suppression tries to push desires, impulses, and instincts underground through force of will. It does not deal with the source of the desire. It only manages its expression, and not very effectively. What gets suppressed tends to resurface, often with more force for having been pushed down. This is why Paul's verdict on the approach in Colossians 2:23 is so pointed: self-imposed asceticism and the harsh treatment of the body have "an appearance of wisdom" but are "of no value in stopping the indulgence of the flesh." They look spiritual. They do not work.
​
Denial in the scriptural sense is something different. It is not the suppression of desire but the redirection of source. To deny yourself, in the context of following Jesus, is to stop looking to yourself as the foundation and provider of your own life. It is releasing the assumption that you can secure what you need through your own efforts, your own plans, your own management. It is not a diminishment of who you are. It is a reorientation of where your life comes from.
​
The self that is denied is the self that tries to live independently of God. The self that remains, the one hidden with Christ in God, is actually more fully you than the striving version ever was.
What this looks like in practice
If dying to self is not suppression, performance, or self-punishment, what is it?
​
It is the practice of returning. When the impulse rises to manage, control, perform, or secure life through your own effort, dying to self is the moment of release, the turning back to: my life is not my own, and I am not the one holding it together. It is the quiet surrender of the need to be right, the need to prove yourself, the need to be enough through your own doing.
​
Paul describes the ongoing shape of this in Galatians 5:16: "Walk by the Spirit, and you will not gratify the desires of the flesh." He does not say: work hard against the flesh until you overcome it. He says: walk by the Spirit. The movement is toward something, not away from something. When you are genuinely walking in the Spirit, genuinely living from union with God, the pull of the flesh loses its authority. Not through effort against it, but through the reality of what you are already walking in.
​
This is why dying to self, properly understood, is not exhausting. Suppression is exhausting. Striving is exhausting. But returning, again and again, to the truth that you have already died and your life is hidden in Christ: that is rest. The pressure is off. You are not the one you have been waiting for. He is already within you, and He is the one doing the living.
The bottom line
Dying to self is not a performance. It is a reality you return to.
​
The old self, defined by independence from God, by sin, by striving apart from its source, was crucified with Christ. That death is past tense and accomplished. What remains is you, hidden with Christ in God, living from a source that is not your own effort but His life within you.
​
The daily practice is not grinding yourself down into nothing. It is releasing, again and again, the assumption that you are the one holding your life together, and returning to the truth that the one who has already died is not who you are anymore. You are the new creation. And the new creation does not need to kill itself to find God. It needs only to live from Him.
Go Deeper
-
Romans 6-8: Living from the Kingdom - Deep Dive - Watch Video, Read ebook
"Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, the new creation has come: The old has gone, the new is here! All this is from God, who reconciled us to himself through Christ and gave us the ministry of reconciliation: that God was reconciling the world to himself in Christ, not counting people's sins against them. And he has committed to us the message of reconciliation."
2 Corinthians 5:17-19